UCSF Orthopedic Surgeons Test Artificial Back Disc

July 30, 2002
News Office: Maureen McInaney (415) 502-6397

UCSF Medical Center orthopedic surgeons are investigating the effectiveness of an implant that may replace damaged lower back discs. European patients who have received the stainless steel and plastic assembly in place of degenerated discs have reported significant improvement in back and leg pain after a minimum of seven years of follow-up, according to the UCSF investigators.

"In European clinical trials, the implant alleviated disc-related lower back pain while maintaining spine mobility - and eliminated the need for fusion of the lower spine," said Dr. David S. Bradford, UCSF Medical Center orthopedic surgeon and lead investigator of the UCSF study.

UCSF Medical Center is one of 13 centers currently evaluating Prosdisc®, which replaces discs damaged by degeneration, bulging, herniation or thinning. The objective of the randomized clinical trial, which will enroll approximately 510 patients over four years, is to compare the safety and effectiveness of the Prodisc® implant to spinal fusion surgery. In fusion, the mainstay of surgical treatment for low back pain caused by degenerative disc disease (DDD), surgeons use rods and screws attached to the bones of the spine to hold them until the bones heal together.

While lumbar spine fusion has increased at the highest rate of any spinal procedure in the last 10 years, advisability for patients, techniques and results remain controversial and unclear, according to Bradford. The ability of the bone to heal or fuse varies. In addition, spinal fusion at one or more levels can cause stiffness and decreased motion in the spine and more stress to be transferred to adjacent levels of the spine.

Consequently, not all patients have a successful outcome, he said.

"Most important, fusion is not targeted toward restoration of normal structure and function," said Bradford. "This prospective, randomized study will tell us is if the Prodisc® can eliminate back pain by preserving or restoring motion in the spine, restoring the structure and height of damaged vertebrae and restoring the normal biomechanics of the lumbar spine."

The artificial disc device, developed in France in the late 1980s, has two porous cobalt-chrome plates, with stabilizing keels that integrate into adjacent vertebrae, and a polyethylene ball-bearing core. The core functions on a ball-and-socket principle to fulfill the role of healthy discs -- which permit limited motion and flexibility, while maintaining stability in specific segments of the spine and absorbing and distributing load.

The Prodisc® implants are suited for patients with degenerative disc disease at one or two levels of the spine. Patients should be between the ages of 18 and 60 and are eligible if they have failed at least six months of conservative therapy. Some patients will receive the Prodisc®, while others will receive the currently accepted treatment, spinal fusion.

Back pain is the most common ailment of the working-age adult, affecting over 4 million individuals each year in the United States. It is estimated that treatment of lower back pain in the United States costs more than $100 billion a year. While most acute episodes of low back pain respond well to non-operative treatment, managing chronic low back pain remains a difficult challenge, according to Bradford.

The rate of back surgeries, including fusion of the spine, has increased by more than 600 percent between 1979 and 1990. In addition to spinal fusion, current treatments also include disc excision (discectomy) and the use of injections, electrothermal therapies and implanted neural stimulators and medication dispensers.

In addition to artificial disc replacement, researchers in the spinal disorders division at UCSF Medical Center also are investigating disc regeneration using techniques of cellular and molecular biology and artificial joint creation (intervertebral disc arthroplasty). This may include replacing only the center -- or nucleus -- of the disc, according to the UCSF researchers.

The Prodisc® prosthesis, manufactured by Spine Solutions, Inc. of New York, is one of two similar devices being investigated. A separate study is analyzing the effectiveness of the SB Charite III Dynamic Disc Spacer, manufactured by the Link Spine Group in Branford, Conn. This device was developed in the mid-1980s at the Berlin Charite Clinic in Germany.

Additional investigators on the UCSF clinical trial of Prodisc® include UCSF Medical Center orthopedic surgeons Dr. Serena Hu, UCSF associate professor of orthopedic surgery; Dr. Sigurd H. Berven, UCSF assistant professor of orthopedic surgery; Dr. Bobby K. B. Tay, UCSF assistant professor of orthopedic surgery; and Dr. Vedat Deviren, UCSF assistant professor of orthopedic surgery.

For more information about the UCSF study, sponsored by Spine Solutions, Inc., contact research coordinator Robin Roland at (415) 502-5333.

This news release has been modified for the Web site